Here's the first few links I've found. I'm just going to make a list, then start narrowing it down to real possibilities.
Holmes County, Ohio, Charm Countryview Inn offers more than comfortable lodging. Come in, take your shoes off and make yourself at home. Many folks have made Charm Countryview Inn their second home. This Amish Country bed and breakfast is a place to relax, refresh your spirit, rejuvenate your mind and breathe in some pure Amish country air. Welcome to our home. We look forward to seeing you soon.
~ Paul & Naomi, Inn Keepers
Furnished with late 1800 antique furniture, the Hasseman House Bed & Breakfast is indeed a step back into a bygone era. Each room is a visual delight, and you will fall in love with the intricate woodwork and original stained glass. The entire Bed & Breakfast surrounds you with charm and beauty from the kitchen, parlor, and dining room on the first floor, to the Attic (Honeymoon Suite) at the top of the house featuring soaring ceilings, a sitting area, and private bath. The Hasseman House features four cozy guest rooms, each with private baths. Two of the rooms offer Jacuzzis. After a restful nights sleep, enjoy a hearty breakfast in the dining room.
Enjoy a truly unique lodging experience in this relocated and resurrected c. 1820 log house and c. 1840 addition. Hisrich Hills House Bed & Breakfast and ArtFarm, moved from Coshocton County, Ohio to our location in Tuscarawas County, the main structure recreates a pioneer atmosphere with authentic period furnishings and a romantic cooking fireplace. The adaptive reuse of the timber frame addition combines historic and contemporary aesthetics with modern conveniences.
Our Berlin, Ohio Bed & Breakfast offers some of the most peaceful Ohio Amish Country lodging available. Visit Bluebird Haven Bed and Breakfast to relax and be refreshed. We are back in a quarter-mile lane and surrounded by woods. At our Amish owned and operated bed and breakfast, you will find a clean, comfortable place to relax. Experience a peaceful, quiet country retreat without the intrusion of TV or phone. Enjoy our perennial gardens, a lawn swing under the trees, many varieties of birds and wildlife, and a grassy path through the woods. You may wish to sit on the back deck outside the private entrance to the bed and breakfast to watch the birds or just to enjoy the view.